top of page
Shelsky's Of Brooklyn - Catering
Questions about your order? Click Here
In an effort to reduce the amount of disposable plastic we use (because, unfortunately, we still must use quite a bit), we don’t offer disposable plastic eating utensils.
We do, however, offer bamboo sustainable disposable plates and flatware for $4/person.
Pickup, ASAP (in 15 minutes)
Popular ItemsUtensilsSmoked Fish PlattersBagel & Schmear PlatterFruit And Platters of Sweet ThingsSmoked & Cured Fish, and Simple Schmear Sandwich Platter: Your choice of at least 12 of the following sandwiches beautifully arranged on a platter(s)Shelsky's Deli Meat PlatterDelicatessen Sandwich Platter: Your choice of at least 12 of the following sandwiches beautifully arranged on a platter(s) (Minimum 8 Sandwiches) - Served with homemade potato salad, coleslaw, assorted pickles, deli mustard, and Russian dressing.Crudités PlatterSalads & SpreadsHerringChallahJuice, Soda, & WaterCoffee & Tea Service
Delivery & Pickup MenuPopular ItemsUtensilsSmoked Fish PlattersBagel & Schmear PlatterFruit And Platters of Sweet ThingsSmoked & Cured Fish, and Simple Schmear Sandwich Platter: Your choice of at least 12 of the following sandwiches beautifully arranged on a platter(s)Shelsky's Deli Meat PlatterDelicatessen Sandwich Platter: Your choice of at least 12 of the following sandwiches beautifully arranged on a platter(s) (Minimum 8 Sandwiches) - Served with homemade potato salad, coleslaw, assorted pickles, deli mustard, and Russian dressing.Crudités PlatterSalads & SpreadsHerringChallahJuice, Soda, & WaterCoffee & Tea Service
Delivery & Pickup Menu
Popular Items
$69/12" Platter. $94/16" Platter. $119/18" Platter. Diced fresh "all-year-round" fruit and a selection of the freshest seasonal fruit the market has to offer.69.00 USD
Includes cups, sleeves, stirrers, lids, milk, half and half, oat milk, Sugar in the Raw, and sweetener.35.00 USD
Our pastrami is slowly cured with a special blend of spices. It is then smoked over hard wood and steamed to tender awesomeness. Served on rye with deli mustard.28.99 USD
Our ccorned beef is cured gently for a week to ensure the full complexity of the special cure is in every bite. Steamed and sliced, our corned beef sandwich is mind-meltingly delicious. Served on rye with deli mustard.27.99 USD
Our homemade, thinly-sliced roasted turkey, cole slaw, Swiss cheese, & Russian dressing served on your choice of bread.22.99 USD
Our smoked whitefish salad is made with wild-caught whitefish from the great lakes. This is not a mayonnaise salad with some fish byproduct. This is a premium whitefish salad dressed with a little mayonnaise. It tastes like smoke and cold-water fresh fish Want More? Add more quantities using modifiers18.48 USD
Utensils
$4/person. In an effort to reduce waste, we don't offer complimentary plates and flatware. What we do offer, though, is this sustainable, disposable premium bamboo product. It's sturdy, looks great, and is perfect for any gathering.4.00 USD
Smoked Fish Platters
$28/person - 8 person minimum. Hand-sliced Eastern Gaspé Nova, beautifully arranged on a platter, and served with assorted Shelsky's bagels, plain & scallion cream cheese, thinly-sliced red onions, and capers.
(Includes 1 1/2 bagels/person. So, an 8 person platter comes with 12 bagels and enough cream cheese for those 12 bagels)224.00 USD
$29/person - 8 person minimum. Hand-sliced Eastern Gaspé Nova, beautifully arranged on a platter, and served with assorted Shelsky's bagels, plain & scallion cream cheese, thinly-sliced red onions, capers. tomatoes, cucumbers and lemon.
(Platter comes with 1 1/2 bagels/person. So, an 8 person platter comes with 12 bagels and enough cream cheese for those 12 bagels)232.00 USD
$34/person - 8 person minimum. Hand-sliced Scottish salmon,
house-cured gravlax, & pastrami smoked salmon beautifully arranged on a platter. Platter includes assorted Shelsky's bagels, plain & scallion cream cheese, sliced red onions and capers.
(Includes 1 1/2 bagels/person. So, an 8 person platter comes with 12 bagels and enough cream cheese for those 12 bagels)272.00 USD
$35/person - 8 person minimum. Hand-sliced Scottish salmon,
house-cured gravlax, & pastrami smoked salmon beautifully arranged on a platter. Platter includes assorted Shelsky's bagels, plain & scallion cream cheese, sliced red onions, capers, tomatoes, lemons, and cucumber.
(Includes 1 1/2 bagels/person. So, an 8 person platter comes with 12 bagels and enough cream cheese for those 12 bagels)280.00 USD
$40/person - 8 person minimum. Hand-sliced eastern Gaspé Nova, smoked wild Alaskan sable, rich kippered (baked) salmon, and whole boned-out Lake Michigan whitefish beautifully arranged on a platter. Served with assorted Shelsky's bagels, plain & scallion cream cheese, thinly-sliced red ions, and capers.
(Includes 1 1/2 bagels/person. So, an 8 person platter comes with 12 bagels and enough cream cheese for those 12 bagels)320.00 USD
$41/person - 8 person minimum. Hand-sliced eastern Gaspé Nova, smoked wild Alaskan sable, rich kippered (baked) salmon, and whole boned-out Lake Michigan whitefish beautifully arranged on a platter. Served with assorted Shelsky's bagels, plain & scallion cream cheese, thinly-sliced red ions, capers, tomatoes, cucumbers, and lemons.
(Includes 1 1/2 bagels/person. So, an 8 person platter comes with 12 bagels and enough cream cheese for those 12 bagels)328.00 USD
$45/person - 8 person minimum. Hand-sliced eastern Gaspé Nova, Scottish smoked salmon, pastrami smoked salmon, whole boned-out Lake Michigan whitefish, and house-pickled herring with cream sauce and onions. Served with assorted Shelsky's bagels, plain & scallion cream cheese, thinly-sliced red onions, and capers.
(Includes 1 1/2 bagels/person. So, an 8 person platter comes with 12 bagels and enough cream cheese for those 12 bagels)360.00 USD
$46/person - 8 person minimum. Hand-sliced eastern Gaspé Nova, Scottish smoked salmon, pastrami smoked salmon, whole boned-out Lake Michigan whitefish, and house-pickled herring with cream sauce and onions. Served with assorted Shelsky's bagels, plain & scallion cream cheese, thinly-sliced red onions, capers, tomatoes, cucumbers, and lemons.
(Includes 1 1/2 bagels/person. So, an 8 person platter comes with 12 bagels and enough cream cheese for those 12 bagels)368.00 USD
$34/person - 8 person minimum. Your choice of 6 of the following salads:
* Shelsky's smoked whitefish salad
* Baked salmon salad
* Seriously great tuna salad
* Smoked bluefish salad with roasted hazelnuts, oranges, and fennel
* Pickled herring salad
* Chicken salad with grapes and pecans
* Egg salad with cornichons
* Traditional cucumber salad
* Citrus-roasted beet salad
* Chopped liver
* Delicatessen potato salad
* Coleslaw
* Macaroni salad
* Health salad
* Riesling-braised sauerkraut
* Assorted pickles (half sour, full sour, & pickled green tomatoes)
Served with your choice of assorted Shelsky's bagels, sliced rye and pumpernickel bread, or an assortment of bagels and sliced rye and pumpernickel bread.200.00 USD
Bagel & Schmear Platter
$9/person. Your choice of assorted Shelsky’s Brooklyn Bagels, sliced and arranged on a platter. Served with plain and scallion cream cheese. Please include in the special requests field below, whether you’d like to swap out the plain or the scallion cream cheese.108.00 USD
Fruit And Platters of Sweet Things
$69/12" Platter. $94/16" Platter. $119/18" Platter. Diced fresh "all-year-round" fruit and a selection of the freshest seasonal fruit the market has to offer.69.00 USD
Medley of only the freshest fruit cut into bite-sized pieces, served with fresh-picked mint84.00 USD
$10/person. Minimum 8 people. Truly AMAZING granola served with labneh and fresh berries.80.00 USD
$15/person. A bountiful platter of assorted homemade rugelach, chocolate babka, honey cake, gooey coconut macaroons, and mini black & white cookies.150.00 USD
$25/person. 10 people minimum. Selection of croissants, almond croissants, pain au chocolat, lemon-poppy muffins, pain au raisin, and blueberry scones, served with Kate's creamery butter, clotted cream, and Sarabeth's fruit preserves.250.00 USD
Smoked & Cured Fish, and Simple Schmear Sandwich Platter: Your choice of at least 12 of the following sandwiches beautifully arranged on a platter(s)
The classic - Eastern Gaspe Nova, and your choice of scallion or plain cream cheese. Served on your choice of bagel or bialy.19.99 USD
Eastern Gaspe Nova, smoked whitefish salad, pickled herring and sour pickles served with your choice of bagel or bialy.21.99 USD
Tomatoes, pickled tomatoes, cilantro, jalapeños, thinly-sliced red onions, apple horseradish sauce, and mayonnaise. Served on your choice of bread.14.49 USD
Baked salmon salad, hand-sliced Eastern Gaspe Nova, horseradish cream cheese, tomatoes, thinly-sliced red onions, capers, and lemon juice. We suggest this sandwich on a toasted bialy, but we're happy to serve it on your bread of choice.21.99 USD
Eastern Gaspe Nova, wild-Alaskan sable, pickled herring with cream sauce and onions, and scallion cream cheese. Served on your choice of bagel or bialy. (Peter invented it on a bialy. It's a mess. BUT SO WORTH THE MESS!)21.49 USD
House-cured gravlax, butter, thinly-sliced red onion, tomatoes, capers, and lemon juice. We suggest this sandwich on a toasted bialy, but we're happy to serve it on your bread of choice.21.49 USD
Hand-sliced wild -laskan sable, scallion cream cheese, and tomatoes. We suggest this sandwich on a toasted bialy, but we're happy to serve it on your bread of choice.21.49 USD
Lake sturgeon, house-cured gravlax, cream cheese, tomato and red onion. Served on your choice of bagel or rye bread.24.49 USD
California lake sturgeon, butter, and thinly-sliced red onion. We suggest this sandwich on a toasted bialy, but we're happy to serve it on your bread of choice.23.49 USD
Lake sturgeon, plain cream cheese, fresh jalapeños, sour pickles, and tomato. Served on your choice of bread.24.49 USD
Our AWESOME smoked whitefish salad, horseradish cream cheese, and wasabi tobiko. Served on your choice of bread.22.99 USD
Rich and silky kippered salmon, apple horseradish sauce, plain cream cheese and pickled herring salad. Served on your choice of bread.21.49 USD
Pastrami-smoked salmon, honey mustard, horseradish cream cheese and thinly-sliced red onion. We invented the sandwich on seeded rye. We suggest it on seeded rye. But, feel free to make a different bread choice. It's your sandwich. But, we're right. Just sayin'!20.99 USD
Smoked peppered mockerel, vegetable cream cheese, and cucumber salad. Served on your choice of bagel or rye bread.18.99 USD
Our American dream series... Your choice of baked salmon salad (red), smoked whitefish salad (white), or smoked bluefish salad, with roasted hazelnuts, fennel, & oranges (blue), topped with cucumber salad and sriracha hot sauce. Served on your choice of bread.
Bread Choice21.49 USD
Shelsky's seriously great tuna salad. Served on a bed sliced jalapenos, topped with Malaysian chili sambal (contains fermented shrimp paste) and crispy Chinatown fried onions. Served on your choice of bread. *WARNING - THIS SANDWICH IS SPICY. WE'RE NOT JOKING.18.99 USD
3.49 USD
8.99 USD
9.49 USD
11.49 USD
10.49 USD
9.99 USD
We blend Laoganma, (angry lady sauce aka spicy chili crisp) with cream cheese. It's loaded with chilies, soy nuts, fried onions, Sichuan peppercorns, and msg. IT. IS. AWESOME.11.49 USD
10.49 USD
House whipped, fresh scallion with the all natural tofu flavor on your bagel, bialy, or rye bread of your choice10.99 USD
17.49 USD
Our baked salmon salad is RICH, and if your are absolutely fah-mished, then having it on a bagel or bialy will totally satisfy you!17.49 USD
We're not joking. Our tuna salad is seriously great. Have a tuna sandwich. When was the lost time you just had a tuna sandwich. Go for it. It's a classic done right.15.99 USD
We make our smoked bluefish salad with beautiful bluefish from Rhode Island. We mix it with roasted hazelnuts, fennel, and oranges. Served on your choice of bread.18.49 USD
Our egg salad has little disks of cornichons (pickled gherkins) in it. Served on your choice of bread.13.99 USD
Our pickled herring salad is brown. It isn't pretty. But it's SO TASTY! It's great with some butter and thinly-sliced red onion. Served on your choice bread.14.99 USD
17.99 USD
15.99 USD
Shelsky's Deli Meat Platter
Your choice of 3 of our classic Jewish deli meats, beautifully arranged on a platter and served with your choice of 2 sides, assorted pickles, sliced rye and pumpernickel, spicy brown deli mustard, and Russian dressing.231.92 USD
Your choice of 4 of our classic Jewish deli meats, beautifully arranged on a platter and served with your choice of 2 sides, assorted pickles, sliced rye and pumpernickel, spicy brown deli mustard, and Russian dressing.255.92 USD
Delicatessen Sandwich Platter: Your choice of at least 12 of the following sandwiches beautifully arranged on a platter(s) (Minimum 8 Sandwiches) - Served with homemade potato salad, coleslaw, assorted pickles, deli mustard, and Russian dressing.
Our pastrami is slowly cured with a special blend of spices. It is then smoked over hard wood and steamed to tender awesomeness. Served on rye with deli mustard.28.99 USD
Our ccorned beef is cured gently for a week to ensure the full complexity of the special cure is in every bite. Steamed and sliced, our corned beef sandwich is mind-meltingly delicious. Served on rye with deli mustard.27.99 USD
We roast Dellapietra's beef rounds slowly to a beautifully rosy-pink medium-rare. We then thinly slice it and gently fold it onto an Orwasher's Bakery onion roll with butter, Dijon mustard, and crispy fried Chinese onions. It's definitely best on that roll, but we're happy to serve it on your choice of bread.20.99 USD
Our homemade, thinly-sliced roasted turkey, cole slaw, Swiss cheese, & Russian dressing served on your choice of bread.22.99 USD
Peter Shelsky's childhood favorite.... Corned beef tongue seved on rye with deli mustard26.99 USD
Chopped liver and apple horseradish sauce served on an onion roll17.99 USD
Crudités Platter
A bountiful platter of fresh crudités served with fines herbes fromage blanc dipping sauce89.00 USD
Salads & Spreads
Our smoked whitefish salad is made with wild-caught whitefish from the great lakes. This is not a mayonnaise salad with some fish byproduct. This is a premium whitefish salad dressed with a little mayonnaise. It tastes like smoke and cold-water fresh fish Want More? Add more quantities using modifiers18.48 USD
$18.48/half pound. Made from our rich kippered salmon, this spread is great on a bagel, bialy, or rye bread!18.48 USD
Roasted hazelnuts, orange, and fennel Want More? Add more quantities using modifiers20.48 USD
$11.99/half pound. We're not kidding. It really is seriously great!11.99 USD
$10.49/half pound. Our pickled herring salad may not be the prettiest salad of the bunch, but surely one of the tastiest! In fact, it serves perfectly as a sweet and sour compliment to our smoked whitefish or baked salmon salads. It's basically a party in your mouth.10.49 USD
$27.49/half pound. We love pickling fish! And, while pickled herring is our most popular, pickled lox also deserves your attention. We start by desalinating our salty belly lox in fresh water for 3 days, then we pickle it wine vinegar and our own blend of spices. Slightly sweet, it's a great side-dish, appetizer or snack. Feeling luxurious? Order it with some cream sauce and pickled onions.27.49 USD
$7.49/half pound. Egg salad can be divisive. You either love it or hate it. We love it. And if you're in that camp, then you'll LOVE ours. It's got little slices of cornichons in it!7.49 USD
$10.99/half pound. We gently poach chickens from our friends at Los Paisanos Butcher Shop. We then break apart the pieces, and toss them with pecans, grapes, and celery. It's just a great chicken salad.10.99 USD
$8.99/half pound. We sauté chicken livers with onions, then hand-chop them into a chopped liver that walks the line between smooth and chunky. Duck fat, cognac, and hard-cooked eggs round out our chopped liver. It's got that rich unctuousness that makes it an irresistible classic.8.99 USD
$14.49/half pound. We make our spicy shrimp salad with Kewpie brand Japanese mayo, masago, togarashi and sesame oil.14.49 USD
$22.49/half pound. Gently steamed and then hand picked, we mix our Canadian lobster with a kiss of mayonnaise and tarragon.22.49 USD
Traditional appetizing cucumber salad Want More? Add more quantities using modifiers7.49 USD
$7.49/half pound. Give your table a pop of color with this citrus and thyme scented roasted beet salad.7.49 USD
$4.49/half pound. We use arborio rice in our rice pudding! All that starch makes it luscious and creamy! Oh, and we add raisins. We know they're divisive. We love raisins in our rice pudding. If you don't, your opinion is wrong.4.49 USD
$4.49/half pound. Macaroni salad is part of the holy trinity of delicatessen salads. In fact, it is the only acceptable form of pasta salad. We make ours with a homemade dressing that has a nice little zing to it!4.49 USD
$4.49/half pound. I've never met a potato that I didn't like, and potato salad can really never be bad. Well, maybe it can.... But, ours is outstanding!4.49 USD
$4.49/half pound. Nothing is worse than sad, flavorless coleslaw. Ok, yes, of course, war, famine, illness, they're all worse... But, you get what I'm sayin'. Our coleslaw though is AWESOME!4.49 USD
$4.99/half pound. "What's health salad?" is a question we often get asked. It's like coleslaw's healthier cousin... Vinegar-based slaw, oregano. A great foil to fatty pastrami.4.99 USD
8.00 USD
8.00 USD
8.00 USD
2.00 USD
Herring
$3.50/fillet. The Jewish appetizing shop classic done right, Jumbo salted herring filets are desalinated, and then pickled in wine vinegar with spices and a bit of sugar. Choose from herring in wine sauce or herring with cream and onions.3.50 USD
$5.25/fllet. Large baby herring fillets are salted and pickled with warming spices and beetroot powder giving them a salty and sweet red hue. Great with some cream cheese and pumpernickel bread.5.25 USD
$3.75/fillet. We marinate our classic pickled herring in a homemade whole grain dijon mustard and fresh dill sauce.3.75 USD
$3.50/rollmop. Our pickled herring pounded thin and wrapped around full sour pickles.3.50 USD
$3.50/rollmop. Our pickled herring pounded thin and wrapped around pickled onions.3.50 USD
$5/fillet. Schmaltz herring is velvety salted herring, preserved in oil. Think of it as herring confit. Sorta.5.00 USD Sold Out
Sold Out
$4.25/fillet. These French herring fillets are gently brined and then smoked over oak. They're awesome cut up and served with warm fingerling potatoes and Dijon mustard.4.25 USD
Challah
Our braided challahs are gorgeous! And, as beautiful as they are, they're even more delicious. Our challah comes from our friends at Colson Patisserie. Be sure to buy an extra one, so you can let it get stale and make French toast!9.99 USD
Baked fresh every Friday limited (only available fridays)160.00 USD
Juice, Soda, & Water
Includes sustainable cups, lids, and straws.4.00 USD
2.50 USD
1.50 USD
1.50 USD
1.25 USD
1.50 USD
2.25 USD
12.99 USD
Coffee & Tea Service
Includes cups, sleeves, stirrers, lids, milk, half and half, oat milk, Sugar in the Raw, and sweetener.35.00 USD
(For 60+ People) (per person)
Includes cups, sleeves, stirrers, lids, milk, half and half, oat milk, Sugar in the Raw, and sweetener.4.00 USD
Per box.
Includes cups, sleeves, stirrers, lids, milk, half and half, oat milk, Sugar in the Raw, and sweetener.36.00 USD
Per box.
Includes cups, sleeves, straws, lids, milk, half and half, oat milk, simple syrup, and sweetener.60.00 USD
bottom of page